Charfi’s criticism of Charfi Stands with contradictions of modernist reading of heritage and religious texts The issue of writing the Holy Qur'an in the life of .prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) as a sample

Abstract

The reason for the creation of this article is a set of contradictions observed from the books of the Tunisian thinker Abdelmajid Charfi. Attempting to re-read what came in the heritage and what is related to the Sunnah and Qur'an, according to Western methods and mechanisms and based on the precursors and purposes, will undoubtedly result in contradictions and producer of fabrication.One of those remarkable contradictions is the issue of writing the Holy Qur'an in the life of prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him). Where the author fluctuated between the negation and confirmation. These papers have been drawn to identify this contradiction and indicate its resources, and to decide on its truth and present its evidence. The contradiction in the results of scientific research is a sign of the invalidity of his methodology, and it calls into question its integrity and objectivity. One of the most important findings of the research: that the Charfi’s fluctuation between saying the writing of the Qur'an and his denials due to two reasons: The denial of writing is a way to question the integrity of the Koran from distortion, and the confirmation of writing the Qur'an is to deny the invocation of the Sunnah.